Reflecting on: New York Magazine, 20 November, 2011, When Did the GOP Lose Touch With Reality? by David Frum
I thought this was a concise and insightful analysis of what's wrong with conservative USA today, through the eyes of a life-long conservative insider and W-Bush era White House speechwriter. One commenter on Metafilter called it David Frum "losing his political religion", which describes the piece beautifully, though Frum argues that he hasn't moved so much as the party has been hijacked out from under its former standard-bearers.
Frum just nails the current reality on so many points:
- the toxic worldview of Fox News and talk radio, painting the government as the enemy of a beseiged populace having their rights and money drained away from them
- the conservative "alternative knowledge system, with its own facts, its own history, its own laws of economics."
- the 'reform' of campaign finance law that lets unlimited money buy attack ads on behalf of candidates, citing 'freedom of speech' as their justification
- the disaster that is the 'tea party'
- the intentional polarisation of the body politic, crossing lines and using political tactics that were, by convention, never crossed; never used - in effect, the erosion of respect for a system that had served to make America the shining beacon on the hill, in the service of narrow interests and point-scoring.
To be sure, things aren't great in the US (or here, or on the continent, for that matter). Projecting all the blame on the current administration is hardly realistic - and Frum points out the Bush administration's responsibility in letting things get where they were. Obstructing the government's attempts to right a very broken economy can hardly be seen as patriotism.
I think the real disaster engendered by the Republicans today is the breakdown of compassion and commonweal envisioned by the nation's founders. As Frum points out, policies embraced by the right under Republican presidents in the past are now vilified as somehow alien under Obama. If it's not "our policy" it's no good, no matter what it is. And therefore nothing any good can come of the current administration, and therefore no respect for the institutions is justified, and an all-out war to control the institutions is launched, with progress blocked along the way, irrespective of the will of the people. The collapse of the Supercommittee looks like evidence of the same.
It appears that the beauty contest for the Republican presidential nominee is playing into the hands of the more polished and politic players - Romney, I suppose, is the best of a bad lot - the most compromising; the most compromised. And maybe for that reason alone the right - the tea party - find him the least palatable (or maybe it's the Mormon subtext). Least palatable, but possibly the most electable. And in that, perhaps a glimmer of hope for the primary season. And if not, well, it's hard to imagine Americans at large electing any of the other nut cases, so we've got that to look forward to as well. Myself, I'd far prefer another four years of Obama in the White House. So I'll come out early and say that's where my sympathies lie.